IS year 1 · The Hague (WH)

Exam analysis World History

Which topics get the most space, where are the marks and what takes the most thinking? The material of World History worked through, with the places where students in this course go wrong. Free to read.

World History is twelve chapters and twelve lectures, one lecture per chapter, in the first semester of the first year. The written exam decides 60 percent of your grade and combines multiple choice with short open questions; the tutorials carry the other 40 percent through the assignments on primary sources and the group project Telling Stories through Objects. This page is about the shape of that exam rather than about the material itself: how the twelve chapters weigh against each other, where the points sit, what takes the most thinking, how you divide your time, and where students in this course reliably go wrong. The topics below are themes, not chapters, because the book is built that way. Chapter 1 hands you a toolbox and the ten thematic chapters use it again and again, so historicism turns up in weeks 2 and 4, teleology in weeks 4, 7, 10 and 12, and the question of who describes whom in weeks 2, 6, 8 and 12. Each chapter also closes with a link back to the one before it. Revising by chapter gets you through the reading; revising by theme is what a short open question asks for.

Topics of World History by share, expected points, difficulty and study time
TopicShare of the materialexpected pointsDifficultyStudy time
The historian's toolbox11%11%4 out of 511%
Identity and nationalism10%10%4 out of 510%
Religion as practice9%7%5 out of 58%
War and empire9%8%4 out of 58%
Trade networks and world-systems8%9%4 out of 59%
Human rights8%9%3 out of 58%
Slavery, capitalism and race8%9%4 out of 59%
Political order and sovereignty8%9%5 out of 510%
Ecology and the Anthropocene8%8%4 out of 58%
World history today: order and polarity8%8%3 out of 57%
Writing and oral history7%7%3 out of 56%
Modernity and counter-modernity6%5%5 out of 56%

Share of the material

The first thing to notice is how flat this course is. Twelve chapters of roughly the same length, one lecture each, and no topic takes a quarter of the material. The largest theme is about twice the size of the smallest, and the eight in the middle sit within a point or two of each other. In a course with one dominant subject you can afford to gamble on what comes up. Here you cannot, because the multiple choice draws its definitions from all twelve weeks. The historian's toolbox is the largest theme, and not because chapter 1 is long. It is the only one that returns almost every week: historicism and the two kinds of source in weeks 1, 2 and 5, teleology in weeks 4, 7, 10 and 12, anachronism in 4 and 5, presentism in 10, bias in 5, and the question of what commemoration leaves out in 9. Identity and nationalism comes second because two full chapters, the Middle East and North Africa in week 8 and China in week 9, turn on the same question of how a society answers outside pressure. Religion takes third place: chapter 6 is entirely about it, and it also runs through Mali, the Silk Roads, the wars of religion and Afghani. At the other end sit modernity and counter-modernity, writing and oral history, and the concluding chapter. Small does not mean skippable here. Modernity takes the fewest pages and appears in the most weeks, so it is the theme you meet constantly without ever revising it on purpose, and the conclusion hands you the criticisms of World History that fit almost any open question about the earlier weeks.

How to tackle it: Make one table with twelve rows, one per chapter, and four columns: the concept boxes, the primary source, the debate between scholars, and the link back to the week before. The book is built in exactly those columns. Read the table downwards instead of across and the themes on this page appear by themselves.

Where the points are

The exam is written, with multiple choice and short open questions, and it decides 60 percent of your grade. Points follow definitions. Almost every chapter carries its terms in concept boxes, the multiple choice is built on those boxes, and a short open question usually begins by asking you to define the term before you apply it. That is why the topics with many sharp definitions gain on their share of the pages, or at least hold it: political order with its fifteen boxes, trade with five, slavery with five plus the numbers of the trade, human rights with a concept box on almost every page, and the toolbox terms that come back every week. Three topics pull the other way and end up with fewer points than pages. Religion, war and modernity take up a lot of room and give fewer cheap marks, because those chapters argue rather than define. Chapters 6 and 7 carry three concept boxes each and chapter 9 only one, so the marks there sit in the argument and in the case: the four stages by which Burmese Buddhism was made, the reforms that followed each Russian defeat, the road from tianxia through self-strengthening to the Republic of 1912. The third place the points hide is the primary source. Eleven of the twelve chapters have one, and each is short enough to learn in ten minutes: the cockatoo in the Vatican manuscript, the Sundiata epic, the paper shoes of Turfan, the Edict of Nantes, the silver basin in Siegen, the Shwedagon Pagoda, the Order of St. George, Qutb's writing on the United States, the Panthéon de la Guerre, Ben Linder's letter from El Cua, and the excerpt from Black Rainbow. Eleven objects, eleven short open questions waiting to be asked. It is also the same skill the tutorials grade in the other 40 percent, in the source assignments and in Telling Stories through Objects.

How to tackle it: For each of the eleven primary sources write three lines: what it is, what it was for at the time, and what it proves for the chapter's argument. Answer in that order. The third line is where the marks are, because it is the only one that cannot be guessed from the object itself.

What takes the most thinking

Three topics share the top of the scale, and they are hard for the same reason: none of them lets you settle the matter with a definition. Political order and sovereignty is built on words that all carry an everyday meaning that gets in the way, such as state, sovereignty, republic, liberalism and freedom, and the point of that chapter is that those words have a birth date and meant something else before it, so every sentence you write has to be checked against the period you are writing about. Religion as practice has no agreed definition to fall back on at all, and its argument is about the observer rather than about Burma, which leaves nothing you can memorise your way out of. Modernity and counter-modernity does the same at the level of the whole course: it is an argument about the yardstick, not about events. In the middle sit the toolbox, identity, war, trade, slavery and ecology. They are demanding but well signposted, because each comes with definitions you can hold on to while you think. The friendliest chapters are human rights, writing and oral history and the conclusion: a chronology plus a handful of paired terms, which is the easiest shape a chapter can have. The warning belongs with the easy ones. This course is full of pairs that are simple to understand and simple to swap under time pressure: primary and secondary, historicism and meta-history, negative and positive rights, world religion and local religion, deep ecology and social ecology, oral tradition and oral source, hard power and soft power, unipolarity and multipolarity. Understanding a pair and being able to state the difference in one clause are not the same skill, and only the second one is examined.

How to tackle it: Write every pair in the course on a single line: term, difference, term. Bob could talk about deep ecology for a minute and still lost the mark, because the question asked what separates it from social ecology, and that answer is one clause: the value of non-human life against the structures that dominate people and nature alike.

Priorities

The matrix sets the points against the thinking, and five topics land in the corner where both are above average: the historian's toolbox, identity and nationalism, trade networks and world-systems, slavery, capitalism and race, and political order and sovereignty. Start there, and start early, because these are also the topics the other weeks lean on. Miss the toolbox and every later chapter costs you more than it should. Religion, war and empire, ecology and modernity sit in the corner that costs time without paying it back in cheap marks. They still have to be done, so put them in the second pass and give them a fixed number of hours rather than as long as they take. Human rights is the opposite case: sharp definitions, a clean chronology, plenty of marks and not much thinking, which makes it the topic to revise on an evening when you are tired. Writing and oral history and the concluding chapter land lowest, and those are the two you should not read as optional. Week 2 supplies the argument that definitions of civilization built writing into the test of being civilized, which is the same move you meet again in weeks 5, 6 and 8. And the conclusion hands you three criticisms of World History that fit almost any open question about the earlier weeks: too much structure and too little agency, too Anglophone, too dependent on written sources.

How to tackle it: Revise chapter 1 and chapter 12 in one sitting. They are the same toolkit twice, once as an introduction and once as a self-criticism, and having both in your head turns an 'argue for and against' question into a form you can fill in.

Study plan

First pass in the order of the course, one chapter per session, because each chapter answers the one before it and the book says so itself in its link boxes. Chapter 5 orders people where chapter 4 ordered territory. Chapter 6 does to the framework what chapter 5 did to the archive. Chapter 9 repeats the argument of chapter 8 in China. Reading in order costs nothing extra and gives you half the connections for free. Second pass by theme rather than by chapter, and this is the pass most students skip. Collect every place teleology turns up, every pair of terms, every primary source, every theory together with the region where it fails. A short open question rarely stays inside one week: it asks you to compare Egypt with Mali, to hold imperiogenesis against Tilly, to connect counter-modernity in China with Islamic modernism in Egypt. Do not treat the tutorials as separate work. They are 40 percent of the grade and they run on primary sources and on the object you present for Telling Stories through Objects, which is the same skill as the source question on the exam: what it is, what it was for, what it proves. Treat your own object as a twelfth primary source and part of your revision is already done. In the last week, work out loud. The concept boxes as definitions, the pairs as one-line differences, the eleven objects in three lines each, and the three criticisms of World History as the closing paragraph of any question that asks you to argue both ways.

How to tackle it: Luna kept one page per chapter: five concept boxes, one object, one debate, one link to the week before. Twelve pages is a full revision of this course, and it fits on a table.

Key terms per topic

The historian's toolbox

Historicism
The study of history in its unique context, time and place, getting as close as possible to the lived historical experience and refusing present-day moral yardsticks.
Meta-history
The interpretation of history according to an overarching meaning or internal logic, leading towards an ultimate end point.
Historiography
The pre-existing knowledge base and the never-ending debate about a particular historical subject, which a scholar has to show awareness of to claim originality.
Primary and secondary sources
Produced at the time by contemporaries and unmediated by later interpretation, against sources produced afterwards that contain interpretation and assessment.
Teleology
Reasoning from the outcome you expect, so that all evidence is read as working towards it and alternatives are overlooked.
Anachronism
An error of chronological logic, such as calling Ekaterina II a proto-feminist in an age when feminism did not exist.
Presentist perspective
The idea that only the present matters and that today's experience is the measure of all things, as when Confucius is called a human rights activist.
Bias
A prejudice against someone or something that leads to unfair attention or representation in research, as in a slaveholders' archive that records mainly rebellions and runaways.

Identity and nationalism

Nationalism
A political philosophy and political movement focused on an idea and practice of the nation, based on shared identity and solidarity.
Orientalism
An essentialist approach to the Orient, treating Arab and Asian culture and tradition as immutable and stereotyped, with the homo islamicus at its core.
Discourse
A coherent system of words, communications, meaning and practices that together construct our understanding of phenomena.
Post-Colonial Theory
Theory focused on continuities and discontinuities between colonial and post-colonial societies, with power disparities at its centre.
Pan-Arabism
The movement holding that the Arab-speaking countries form one people, whose shared history, linguistic bond and culture matter more than religious or ethnic boundaries.
Islamism
The belief that Islam contains all the answers and solutions for the questions of modernity, expressed through Islamic language and symbols; also called political Islam.
Ijtihad and taqlid
Interpreting the Qur'an and the Sunna for yourself, which Afghani wanted revived, against simply following the rules as they stand.
Jahiliyya
The ignorance of the age before Islam, which Qutb applied to Muslims and their rulers as well, making confrontation with a regime religious and political at once.

Religion as practice

Religion
A set of beliefs inherent to humankind, focused on the divine, which inform a set of practices carried out individually as well as communally.
World religion and local religion
The large and widespread traditions against beliefs and practices deemed unique to a region and community, which do not cross national boundaries.
Religious Syncretism
A combination of different, usually opposing, religious beliefs and practices, a term that implies heterodoxy and therefore needs a standard of orthodoxy.
Botdabada
The word the missionary Judson built from the Pali for Buddha and for text, which the Burmese adopted and use for inherited practice rather than for belief.
Axial Age
Roughly 800 to 200 BCE, where Jaspers and Armstrong place universally oriented thought with a message that crosses societies and political spheres.
Doctrina orientalis
The seventeenth-century Jesuit idea of one doctrine present across Asia, traced to a single teacher and built on doctrines such as reincarnation.
The four stages
The route by which Burmese Buddhism was made: heathens and devil worshippers, then the Christian mould, then scholarly reconstruction after 1817, then fieldwork after 1950.
Age of Discovery
The period from the fifteenth to the eighteenth century when the European seafaring powers commanded the sea and 'discovered' other parts of the globe.

War and empire

Empire
A large geographical space ruled by a single state, with a population that shares a sense of common identity.
War
Violent engagement by at least two identifiable actors commanding force, claiming to represent a group of people to realize a political cause.
Tilly's thesis
War made the state and the state made war: early state building resembled a protection racket, and states are judged on coercion and capital.
Monopoly of force
Weber's test of a state, a territory plus the sole right to use violence within it, which is why empire and state sit so close together.
Marxism
Political philosophy developed by Karl Marx in Das Kapital, seeing the world as driven by structural and material factors that determine its development.
The Order of St. George
The military order Ekaterina II founded in 1769, whose ribbon travelled through the Soviet Guards Ribbon to become an official symbol of victory in 2005.
Decade of death
Krementsov's name for 1914 to 1923, in which fifteen to twenty million people died through war, revolution, civil war and terror.
Great Patriotic War
The war that cost more than twenty-five million Soviet dead and became the founding myth of the state.

Trade networks and world-systems

Silk Roads
The trade routes connecting Asia, Europe and Africa, by land and by sea, named in the nineteenth century by Ferdinand von Richthofen.
World System Theory
The world divided into core countries with capital-intensive production, periphery countries with labour-intensive production, and a semi-periphery between.
Imperiogenesis theory
Mega-empires develop through confrontation between nomadic and sedentary populations, in a mutually reinforcing cycle of organization and confrontation.
Capitalism
An economic system in which the means of production are privately owned rather than owned by the state, and used to generate and maximize profit.
The Great Game
The rivalry between the British and Russian Empires in the nineteenth century over control of the central Asian landmass.
The Great Divergence
The process by which Europe's GDP per capita grew much faster than that of the rest of the world; before roughly 1800 all places were about equally prosperous.
Economy
The social arrangements that provide for material and immaterial needs, with social actors, institutions as formal and informal rules, and technologies.
Entrepot ports
The harbours around southern India and Sumatra where goods changed hands, so that neither ships nor camels ever covered the whole route.

Human rights

Human Rights
Norms and principles with universal application, codified in the Universal Declaration of 1948 and translated into law, in three generations of rights.
Negative Rights
Rights that prevent people from being subjected to a specific kind of action, such as limits on the state's power to coerce or abuse citizens.
Positive Rights
Rights that seek subjection to an action seen as just, such as the state's duty to treat citizens equally.
Criticism towards Human Rights
Five objections raised since 1948: essentially Western norms, unclear whether offered or claimed, ambiguously formulated, unevenly enforced, and ineffective.
Cold War
The rivalry between the United States and the Soviet Union from 1945 to 1989, capitalism against communism, which stayed cold apart from hot wars in the developing world.
Vietnam Syndrome
The perception among Cold War hawks after the defeat in Vietnam that the American public had become overly wary of military intervention.
Democratic Peace Theory
The theory, originally suggested by Kant, that democracies do not fight wars against each other, which has influenced foreign policy.
Thin and thick descriptions
Cmiel's distinction between the simple message that makes abuse visible and the local context that explains the conditions producing it.

Slavery, capitalism and race

Williams thesis
Three claims: capital from slavery funded industrialization, abolition in 1834 followed the declining importance of the West Indies, and racism was the consequence of slavery.
Racism
The belief that humanity can be divided biologically into races with inherited and essential characteristics that determine behaviour and ability.
Second Slavery
The term for the nineteenth century in which industrialization and slavery went together, as with sugar in Cuba and coffee in Brazil.
Casta system
The colonial ordering in which purity of blood attached itself to complexion rather than ancestry, so that social classes became racial classes and a colour line was invented.
Mita
The unfree labour imposed on the indigenous population, which produced the silver of Potosi and shows that coerced labour in the Americas was not only African.
Quilombo
A settlement of runaways far inland, such as Palmares, closer to a neo-African kingdom than to a town and keeping forms of unfreedom inside it.
Candomble
The fusion of African traditions with Catholicism in which orixas serving Oludumare resemble Catholic saints.
The Great Dying
The pandemic after the Spanish conquest in which 60 to 90 percent of local populations died, which drove the demand for imported labour.

Political order and sovereignty

Sovereignty
Supreme or ultimate authority and freedom of action, with no higher source inside or outside.
State
A territorial unit with a monopoly of force, usually with a bureaucracy carrying a legal, fiscal and social order.
Feudalism
A hierarchy of patrons tied to clients, who are patrons to others in turn, with goods, labor and favors flowing up and down it to substantiate claims to rule.
Republic
Government in which authority is held by the people through elective representation, as in the Italian city-states with their assemblies and constitutions.
Constitutional Order
A political order based on a constitution, usually a written document specifying rights and obligations and informing norms.
Theocracy
Rule in which ultimate power rests with God, whose representatives on Earth rule on his behalf.
Politics
The ability to decide who gets what, where, when and how, in Harold Lasswell's definition.
Liberalism
A political philosophy focused on the individual, with individual rights, liberties and equality before the law.

Ecology and the Anthropocene

Environmental History
A field concerned with the impact of the environment on the development of civilizations and with the role of humans in changing the environment.
Environmentalism
The idea that the environment deserves protection and needs effort to restore and improve its condition.
Environmental Determinism
The idea that pre-existing environmental conditions determine the later development of a society, as in Diamond's explanation of the rise of the West.
Anthropocene
The most recent geological epoch, in which human presence has marked the Earth through radioactive fallout, microplastics and heavy metals.
Deep ecology
The rejection of an anthropocentric ethics in which nature is worth only what it is worth to humans; non-human life has intrinsic value.
Social ecology
Bookchin's location of the crisis in hierarchical, exploitative structures that dominate people and nature alike.
Environmental justice
Developing and upholding the rules on protection of the environment for all people, a frame that foregrounds unequal exposure to waste and pollution.
Nuclear imperialism
Imperialist activity to control nuclear production and output, weapons included, at the cost of communities in the developing world.

World history today: order and polarity

World History
The study of history from a world perspective, focusing on the spread of people, goods and ideas and on increased interconnectedness.
The End of History thesis
The thesis that human ideological development ends in the attainment of liberal democracy, popularised when Fukuyama read the Soviet collapse that way.
The Thucydides Trap
Allison's theory that a rising power will challenge a dominant one and that the challenge ends in armed conflict, as with Athens and Sparta.
Cliodynamics
A field based on the quantification of historical phenomena and processes, named after the muse of history, with Peter Turchin as an important exponent.
Power, hard power and soft power
The ability to make others do what you want and what they were not inclined to do, through coercive military and economic instruments or through attraction and co-option.
Unipolarity, bipolarity, multipolarity
An order with one dominant power, with two, or with several strong powers, as in the 1990s, the Cold War and the Concert of Europe.
Global Citizenship
The belief that studying ever-increasing connections helps educate responsible and informed global citizens, the cosmopolitan ideal of the field.
Clash of Civilizations thesis
Huntington's nine civilizations with conflict along the fault lines between them, popular with politicians despite weak empirical support.

Writing and oral history

Meaningful Communication
The deliberate act of transferring information through a verbal medium, speech or writing, or a non-verbal one such as drawing, movement or objects.
Oral History
The study of history through orally transmitted sources, distinguishing oral tradition and oral literature from sources recounting one generation's memory.
The orality-literacy shift
The cognitive change in which expression moved from participatory to internalized and distanced, eternalized but cut off from immediate feedback.
Epistemology
The approach to knowledge and how to arrive at it, taking into account its foundations, methods and validity.
Culture
The ideas and practices that award meaning to activities in human societies.
Civilization
A complex society bound together by common rule, sharing a common territory, identity, means of communication and religion.
Griots
The keepers of royal history in Mali, who rescued the memories of kings from oblivion and mediated conflicts because their knowledge of local history was trusted.
The memory trap
The more a society stored in text, the more power went to those who could read it, as in an Egypt where literacy stayed around 1 percent in the Old Kingdom.

Modernity and counter-modernity

Modernity
A set of ideas focused on rationality, science, secularism, democracy and cosmopolitanism, and the period from the late eighteenth century in which they gained traction.
Enlightenment
The intellectual and scientific movement of the seventeenth and eighteenth century aiming at dominance over natural phenomena through reason and rational deduction.
Counter-Modernity
An intellectual movement against modernity emphasizing the spiritual, nature, ethics and culture, on the idea that Western modernity has lost all ethics and spirituality.
Multiple modernities
The conclusion that modernity was negotiated locally out of lived historical experience, so there is no single universal path to it.
The waiting room of history
Chakrabarty's phrase for where societies said not to have arrived at the modern were placed by a teleological reading of progress.
Tianxia
All under heaven, the hierarchy with China at the centre as leading political power and source of culture for the states on its borders.
Self-strengthening
Western technology and armaments with a Confucian essence, summed up as Chinese learning as substance and Western learning for application.
Islamic modernism
Reform inside religion rather than against it, accepting Western advances selectively, with Islam as the source of solidarity against imperialism.

Where World History usually goes wrong

These mistakes follow from the material itself: concepts that look alike, conditions that have to hold together, an exception that sticks in your head as the main rule.

A primary source is not simply an old source

What goes wrong: Any document from long ago is called a primary source, and a modern article about a medieval object is called secondary only because it was written recently. A source also gets promoted to primary because it looks learned or because the chapter leans on it heavily.

How to do it right: Ask when the source was produced relative to the events, and by whom. Produced at the time, by contemporaries, unmediated by later interpretation, is primary. Produced afterwards, carrying interpretation and assessment, and part of the debate of history, is secondary. The cockatoo image is the primary source; the scholarship identifying the species and dating the manuscript is secondary, and it takes both together to prove that New Guinea and northern Australia lay on existing trading routes.

Why it happens: The pair arrives in week 1 as a matter of age, so age is what sticks. In practice the two kinds turn up in the same sentence, as when the specialist who dates the cockatoo manuscript is quoted right next to the manuscript itself.

How to spot it: If you can state the argument a source makes, it is almost certainly secondary. A primary source has a purpose, not a thesis.

Historicism and meta-history the wrong way round

What goes wrong: Marx and Fukuyama are called historicist because they write about history as a whole, and a close reading of one single period is called meta-history because it goes deep.

How to do it right: Historicism studies a period in its unique context, time and place, refuses universalist claims and refuses present-day moral yardsticks. Meta-history reads one overarching meaning or internal logic across the centuries, leading towards an end point. Marx in Das Kapital and Fukuyama's End of History are meta-history; reading a Sumerian tablet only alongside an understanding of Sumerian society is historicism.

Why it happens: Both terms are about how the past as a whole is interpreted, they are introduced within a page of each other, and the one you read last is the one that sticks.

How to spot it: Ask whether the reading has an end point. If it does, it is meta-history and its risk is teleology. If it refuses to generalise, it is historicism and its limit is that it can say little across periods.

Westphalia as the moment sovereignty was invented

What goes wrong: The year 1648 is presented as the birth of the modern state system, with sovereignty and the formal equality of states created in one treaty, and state and sovereignty are then used as if they meant the same thing.

How to do it right: Sovereignty is supreme or ultimate authority with no higher source inside or outside, and it was already at stake in the Investiture Controversy of 1075 to 1122, when kings answered that their authority came straight from God. A state is a territorial unit with a monopoly of force, usually with a bureaucracy carrying a legal, fiscal and social order, and it grew out of royal courts and taxation from the 1100s onwards. The international parts of the 1648 treaty came from French and Swedish intentions to weaken the Holy Roman Empire, and formal equality between states was invented in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Westphalia is a metaphor for a long evolution, so reading it as the origin commits both anachronism and teleology.

Why it happens: International relations scholarship has long told that origin story, and a single date is easier to hold on to than a long evolution.

How to spot it: A sentence in which 1648 creates something. The Holy Roman Empire continued for another 158 years, which is the fact to reach for.

The Williams thesis read backwards

What goes wrong: Williams is summarised as the man who showed that racism caused the slave trade, and his three parts collapse into one claim about economics.

How to do it right: Williams wrote that slavery was not born of racism, but that racism was the consequence of slavery: once slavery no longer stratified society, racism held white positions in place. That is the third part. The first is that capitalism replaced slavery after British elites had accumulated through slavery the capital that industrialization required. The second is that abolition in the British West Indies in 1834 followed from the declining importance of those colonies, since industry ran on cotton. Close with the consensus: the thesis fits the British case and cannot be transposed to other empires, which is why profitable sugar in Cuba and coffee in Brazil produced the term Second Slavery.

Why it happens: The sentence is famous and half-remembered, and racism causing slavery is the order that feels morally obvious.

How to spot it: If your answer uses racism to explain why the trade began, check it against the climate explanations of Antiquity and against the Iberian purity of blood, which is where heredity enters the story.

One silk road, with silk on it

What goes wrong: The trade is described as a single overland route from Xian to Rome, along which caravans carried silk from one end of Eurasia to the other.

How to do it right: Almost everything the name suggests is wrong. There were routes by land and by sea, shifting with the seasons, the passes, war and markets, and Tim Williams mapped them for UNESCO as a network of 75,000 km. Goods moved while traders mostly did not: cargo was sold on at each market, with the price rising through taxes and scarcity. Silk cloth is absent as a commodity in the Turfan documents and appears instead as payment and collateral, because bolts of silk were money. The network predates the entry of both Rome and China, since exchange already ran between Ur and the Indus valley some 4,500 years ago. And the sea carried far more: one dhow of 300 tons equals about twenty camel trains.

Why it happens: Ferdinand von Richthofen coined the label in the nineteenth century and the romance has outlived every correction. Nobody who actually traded on those routes used the name.

How to spot it: If your answer follows one trader the whole way, or if silk is the cargo rather than the currency, you are describing the label and not the trade.

Orientalism read as personal prejudice

What goes wrong: Orientalism is treated as the private bias of individual European scholars, so the answer becomes a statement that those writers were prejudiced about the region.

How to do it right: Orientalism is an essentialist approach that treats Arab and Asian culture and tradition as immutable and stereotyped, with the homo islamicus at its core: a Muslim whose identity is defined by religion alone. Said's move is to call the whole body of knowledge a discourse, a coherent system of words, meanings and practices that constructs the Orient as everything the West is not and that follows the changing power relations between the two. It is a structure, not a character flaw, which is also why his critique reaches Area Studies: that field drew a different sharp line, between tradition and modernity, while believing it had left Orientalism behind.

Why it happens: The word sounds like an accusation against a person, and Said's book is read as an exposure of bad scholars rather than as an argument about how knowledge is produced.

How to spot it: If your answer would still be true with the word 'prejudiced' in place of the word 'Orientalist', you have not used discourse at all.

Negative and positive rights read as bad and good rights

What goes wrong: Negative rights are taken to mean rights that are denied or withheld, and positive rights to mean the ones that really count.

How to do it right: Negative rights prevent people from being subjected to a specific kind of action, such as limits on the state's power to coerce or abuse its citizens. Positive rights seek subjection to an action seen as just, such as the state's duty to treat citizens equally. Neither is the good one. Reagan's human rights policy was built on the first, on democracy promotion, the free market and anti-communism, while the solidarity activists in Nicaragua demanded the second: self-determination, participatory democracy and socio-economic transformation. Both called it human rights, which is the whole point of the chapter.

Why it happens: In everyday use negative means bad, and the pair arrives in a chapter where one side of a political argument is clearly the more sympathetic one.

How to spot it: Ask what the state must do and what it must refrain from. If your sentence is about refraining, the right is a negative one.

Deep ecology and social ecology swapped

What goes wrong: Bookchin is called a deep ecologist, or deep ecology is described as the strand about inequality and about who bears the damage.

How to do it right: Deep ecology is about the value of nature. It rejects an anthropocentric ethics in which nature is worth only what it is worth to humans, holds that non-human life has intrinsic value, and produced Christopher Stone's argument of 1972 that natural objects should have legal standing. Social ecology, associated with Murray Bookchin, is about social structures: the crisis comes from hierarchical, state-controlled and exploitative structures that dominate people and nature alike, which is what connects environmentalism to struggles against imperialism. Environmental justice and environmental racism follow from the second line, not from the first.

Why it happens: Both arrived at the same moment, both criticise mainstream environmentalism for failing to ask why ecological problems arise, and both sound like intensified versions of the same thing.

How to spot it: If the sentence is about who is harmed and by which structures, you are in social ecology. If it is about what nature is worth without us, you are in deep ecology.

Syncretism used as a description instead of an argument

What goes wrong: Burmese practice is called syncretic and the answer stops there, as if the word had explained the Buddha images, Nats and Weikza shrines standing side by side at the Shwedagon.

How to do it right: Say which sense you are using. In the broad sense every religion is syncretist, since Christianity absorbed local practice wherever it settled, which is why Catholicism in Belgium differs from Catholicism in Mexico, and assimilation or acculturation are the better words there. In the narrow sense it means combining beliefs that cannot go together, such as Nirvana through the cessation of desire beside offerings to Nats made in order to obtain something, and that sense needs a standard of orthodoxy before anything can count as deviation. Name that standard, here Buddhism as sanctified by scripture, and you have an argument instead of a label.

Why it happens: The term feels neutral and technical, and it arrives right after the description of the pagoda, so it reads as the name for what you have just seen.

How to spot it: If you cannot say against which orthodoxy the practice counts as heterodox, you are describing the scholars' scheme rather than what happens in Burma.

An oral source treated as a weak source

What goes wrong: The Sundiata epic or a recorded interview is discounted because it was not written down at the time, while written records are treated as reliable by default and get no criticism at all.

How to do it right: Reliability follows from source critique, not from the medium. Ibn Khaldun applied the same critique to oral and written accounts alike and accepted oral accounts as primary sources, centuries before Ranke. An oral source has limits you should name rather than use as grounds for dismissal: the Sundiata epic serves moral lessons and a dialogue with its audience as much as factual accuracy, and a recorded memory testifies to the past and to the moment of recording at once. That double character is a limitation and a strength, since such sources cover events and perspectives that are otherwise undocumented.

Why it happens: With the Rankean school the discipline narrowed to the written past, most definitions of civilization built writing into the test, and societies that kept their past orally were filed as people without history. That habit is older than any of us and it is still the default setting.

How to spot it: The word 'just' in front of 'an oral tradition', or an answer in which only the oral source needs a paragraph of caution.

Teleology used as a verdict instead of a description

What goes wrong: Every argument that ends somewhere is called teleological, so the word becomes a way of saying that a reading is wrong without saying what is wrong with it.

How to do it right: Teleology is one specific move: you assume an end point, and from then on all evidence is read as working towards it while alternatives are overlooked. To use the word properly you have to name the assumed end point and show which evidence was made to fit it. In the split between a pre-modern and a modern era the end point is the liberal democratic state; in the End of History thesis it is liberal democracy; in Westphalia as the origin of the state system it is the sovereign state. Naming the end point is what turns the word into an argument.

Why it happens: The term arrives in the same breath as the attack on Whig history and the waiting room of history, which makes it sound like a judgement rather than a mechanism you can point at.

How to spot it: If you cannot name the end point the argument is reasoning back from, teleology is not the objection you are looking for.

Empire, state and civilization used as synonyms

What goes wrong: The three words are swapped freely, so a question about empire is answered with the definition of a state, or the Russian Empire is called a civilization because it covered a great deal of ground.

How to do it right: An empire is a large geographical space ruled by a single state, with a population that shares a sense of common identity. A state is a territorial unit with a monopoly of force, usually with a bureaucracy carrying a legal, fiscal and social order, which is close to Weber. A civilization is a complex society bound together by common rule, sharing a common territory, identity, means of communication and religion. An empire therefore presupposes a state, while a civilization does not, and the civilization is the only one of the three that carries communication and religion inside its definition.

Why it happens: The three definitions overlap on territory and on shared identity, and they are introduced six chapters apart, in weeks 1 and 7, so you rarely see them next to each other.

How to spot it: Check whether your sentence needs a monopoly of force. If it does, you are talking about a state, whichever of the three words you wrote down.

Now you know where to start

The summary of World History follows the lectures, week by week. Week 1 is free to read with an account.

Start free with week 1 · Summary World History · See prices

This is a reading guide based on the prescribed literature of the course, the handbook World History for International Studies, and it is written to help you set priorities. Lecture slides and recordings are copyrighted university material and have not been used or summarised here. The weights, the points and the priorities on this page are an estimate of how the material itself weighs, not a prediction of the questions on the exam. Prepare more broadly than what you read here, and check the course manual on Brightspace for the rules that apply to your year.